An ask made in person is far more effective than an email
What they found
A face-to-face request got about 34 times more people to say yes than the identical request sent by e-mail. Askers had no idea - they expected the two channels to work about equally.
How they know
Participants asked 450 strangers to fill in a questionnaire, half by e-mail, half in person, with the exact same script, while the askers' expectations were recorded beforehand.
What it means for you
If a request matters - a client, a favor, an opportunity - do not send it. Say it. Presence carries trust that text strips away.
The limits
One kind of small request between cold strangers - the authors suspect e-mail from someone you know fares better, but that was not tested; and 34x is one study's estimate, not a universal constant.
Try it this week
- Look through your sent mail for a request that went unanswered this month. If it still matters, ask the person face to face this week, using the same words you wrote.
- Before your next important ask, write down how likely you think a yes is by email versus in person. Then make it in person and see whether your guess was too low.
- List the three requests that matter most to you this month, like a raise, a referral or a favor. Plan when and where you will see each person so you can ask face to face.
Questions people ask
Is asking in person better than email?
For the kind of request tested here, by a wide margin. Asking strangers face to face got about 34 times more people to agree than the same request by email, using the exact same script. The striking part is that the people asking expected both channels to work about equally. If you default to email for things that matter, you may be underestimating what a direct ask can do.
Does this apply to emailing people you already know?
Not necessarily. The study tested one small request between cold strangers. The authors suspect that email from someone you know fares better, but that was not tested. So a quick email to a close colleague may work fine. The finding is strongest as a warning about cold outreach, where a request from a stranger in your inbox seems far easier to ignore than one made in person.
Will people really say yes 34 times more often in person?
Not as a fixed rule. The 34x figure is one study's estimate for one small request, filling in a questionnaire, and it is not a universal constant. Your own results will depend on the request, the person and how well you know each other. The safer lesson is about direction: when it matters, asking in person seems to beat email by far more than most people expect.
The takeaway and the notes above are in our own words, not a reproduction of the study. The steps are suggestions, not findings. For the method, the sample and the caveats, read the original.
