Trust ·

Asking for advice makes you look more competent

What they found

People who asked for advice were judged MORE competent by the person they asked - the opposite of what askers feared. Advisers felt affirmed, and the effect grew when the task was difficult.

How they know

In a series of experiments, people worked on difficult brain teasers with a partner who either asked them for advice or didn't, then rated that partner's competence; other studies measured what advice-seekers expected - they predicted looking weaker.

What it means for you

"How would you approach this?" costs nothing, gives you the other person's best thinking, and raises you in their eyes. Ask the person whose respect you want.

The limits

The boost lands mainly in the eyes of the person you ask and holds for difficult matters; on easy tasks it disappears, and asking someone without relevant expertise can backfire.

Try it this week

  1. This week, pick one hard problem you are working on and ask someone with real experience in it: 'How would you approach this?' Choose a person whose respect you want to earn.
  2. Save advice requests for genuinely difficult questions. For easy things you could solve alone in a few minutes, try first, since the competence boost disappears on easy tasks.
  3. After you get the advice, tell the person what you did with it and how it turned out. It closes the loop and shows them their thinking made a difference.

Questions people ask

Does asking for advice make you look weak?

In these experiments, the opposite. People who asked for advice on a difficult task were judged more competent by the person they asked. Advisers felt affirmed by being asked, and the boost grew when the task was hard. Meanwhile, other studies found that advice-seekers expected to look weaker. So the fear is common, but in this research it was misplaced.

When does asking for advice backfire?

Two cases stand out. On easy tasks, the competence boost disappears. And asking someone without relevant expertise can backfire. The effect also lands mainly in the eyes of the person you ask, so do not expect it to spread to everyone else watching. In practice, that means asking the right person about a genuinely hard problem, and solving the simple things yourself.

How do you ask for advice without seeming needy?

Make the question specific and show you have already thought about it. Something like 'I am weighing two options for this client. How would you approach it?' gives the person a real problem to solve. Choose someone whose experience fits the question, since asking someone without relevant expertise can backfire. Then listen, thank them, and follow up later on what you decided.

The takeaway and the notes above are in our own words, not a reproduction of the study. The steps are suggestions, not findings. For the method, the sample and the caveats, read the original.

Ask people what you'd ask an AI.

In Ask on Booking Minds you ask anything without your name, and people who know answer. It is free: no tokens, and no meter running.

Something you could ask there: Has asking someone for advice ever changed how they treated you afterward, for better or worse?

Why it is time to ask people again

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play