The first number on the table pulls the final price toward it
The anchoring effect, one of the most replicated results in psychology: whatever number is mentioned first, even an arbitrary one, drags every later estimate toward it. In a negotiation the opening offer sets the frame both sides bargain within. Name your price first, name it with a reason, and you shape the range.
Try it this week
- Before your next negotiation, decide your opening number in advance and write down the single reason behind it. Say the number first, then the reason, before the other side names theirs.
- When someone else anchors first, do not argue with their number line by line. Restate your own figure and its reason so the conversation moves back to your frame.
- Ask yourself whether a number you heard recently, such as a list price or an early guess, is shaping your view of what is fair. Write down what you would think without it.
Questions people ask
Should you make the first offer in a negotiation?
This research suggests the first number on the table has a strong pull, because later estimates drift toward it, even when it is arbitrary. That gives whoever opens a chance to set the range both sides bargain within. The article adds a condition worth keeping: name your price with a reason. A reason gives the other side something to engage with besides the number itself.
What is the anchoring effect in simple terms?
It is the tendency for the first number you hear to pull your later judgments toward it, even when that number is arbitrary. It is one of the most replicated results in psychology. You can see where it might show up in daily life: a list price on a car, a salary range in a job post, or a contractor's first estimate may all shape what feels reasonable afterward.
How do I resist an anchor someone else sets?
The article describes how anchors work rather than how to resist them, so this is practical advice, not a tested method. Before the talk, set your own number based on your research, so you have something to hold on to. If they open first, acknowledge their figure briefly, then return to your own reasoning. A short pause before you respond can also give you time to reset.
The takeaway and the notes above are in our own words, not a reproduction of the study. The steps are suggestions, not findings. For the method, the sample and the caveats, read the original.
