People from lower social classes negotiate less - and may face more backlash when they do
What they found
People of lower social class were less likely to negotiate pay, raises or promotions. A hiring experiment suggests asking costs them more.
How they know
Four studies with 10,211 people, from Australian employees to US MBA students and a paid online task. Then 1,133 HR professionals rated a fictitious candidate; negotiating made him seem less cooperative, more so when presented as lower class.
What it means for you
If you hesitate to ask, the risk is not imagined. Still, MBA students who negotiated started about $6,450 a year higher.
The limits
A small gap, mostly from self-report surveys that cannot show asking raises pay. The extra penalty showed only in how cooperative he seemed, and only just; its effect on hiring was indirect. One fictitious male candidate, US evaluators; other cultures untested.
Try it this week
- Before your next pay or promotion talk, write one sentence that pairs your ask with a cooperative line, such as 'I want this to work for both of us.' The extra cost in this research showed up as seeming less cooperative.
- Practice the request out loud with a friend twice this week, once for starting pay and once for a raise, so the words feel familiar before the real conversation.
- If you grew up with little money and feel a pull to stay quiet, write down that hesitation, then pick one specific thing you will ask for anyway and the date you will ask.
Questions people ask
Does negotiating your salary actually get you more money?
In this research, MBA students who negotiated started about $6,450 a year higher. But most of the data came from self-report surveys, which cannot show that asking itself raised pay. People who negotiate may differ in other ways, such as their field or the offers they receive. A fair reading is that asking is linked to better starting pay, without any promise that it will work the same way for you.
Is there a backlash for negotiating if you come from a working-class background?
The hiring experiment found a hint of one. When 1,133 HR professionals rated a fictitious candidate, negotiating made him seem less cooperative, a little more so when he was presented as lower class. That extra penalty was small, showed up only in how cooperative he seemed, and affected hiring only indirectly. It involved one male candidate and US evaluators, so it may play out differently in your setting.
Why do people from lower-income backgrounds avoid negotiating pay?
This research measured how often people negotiated, across Australian employees, US MBA students and a paid online task, more than the reasons behind it. The hiring experiment points to one possibility: the hesitation may not be imagined, since asking seemed to cost a lower-class candidate slightly more in how cooperative he looked. If you hold back, it can help to treat that as a real but small risk, not a reason to stay silent.
The takeaway and the notes above are in our own words, not a reproduction of the study. The steps are suggestions, not findings. For the method, the sample and the caveats, read the original.
