Meeting ·

Meeting in person produces more ideas than meeting on video

Engineers and students were paired to brainstorm, half in a room together, half over video. The in-person pairs generated significantly more ideas, and more creative ones. Eye-tracking showed why: on a screen we stare at the face and narrow our focus; in a room the gaze wanders, and so does the mind. For the work that needs new ideas, sit in the same room.

Try it this week

  1. For your next brainstorm, book a room and meet in person, even if it is just one other person. Save video for status updates and decisions that do not need fresh ideas.
  2. If you must brainstorm on video, try turning cameras off for the idea round and letting your eyes roam the room as you talk. This was not tested, but it follows the eye-tracking result.
  3. When you meet to generate ideas, put a whiteboard or paper on the table and let your gaze move. Avoid all staring at one screen together for the first part of the session.

Questions people ask

Are in-person meetings more creative than video calls?

For brainstorming, this study says yes. Engineers and students paired up to generate ideas came up with significantly more ideas, and more creative ones, when they sat in the same room than when they met over video. The comparison was between pairs, so it says more about small brainstorms than about large meetings or other kinds of work.

Why do video calls seem to reduce creativity?

Eye-tracking offered a clue. On a screen, people stared at their partner's face and their focus narrowed. In a room, their gaze wandered around the space, and their thinking seemed to wander with it, which helps when the goal is new ideas. In short, the screen holds attention in one small place, while a room lets it roam.

Is video fine for some kinds of meetings?

The study tested idea generation, not every type of meeting. It does not say video is worse for sharing updates, making decisions or catching up. A practical split is to protect in-person time for the work that needs new ideas and use video freely for the rest. That way you spend travel time where it seems to pay off most.

The takeaway and the notes above are in our own words, not a reproduction of the study. The steps are suggestions, not findings. For the method, the sample and the caveats, read the original.

Meet people. Ask anything.

Booking Minds is a free map of real people you can connect with, and Ask, where nobody sees who asked or who answered.

Something you could ask there: Do your best ideas come out in a room with people, over video, or alone on a walk?

How Booking Minds works

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play